I can't give Elmer and Button anything stuffed! They would tear those stuffed toys up in 3 minutes flat. Captain doesn't do that, though, so he has plenty of stuffed toys at the office where he spends his days.
My babies like little fuzzy stuffed squeaky things. They will tear the squeaker out of a rubber squeaker toy in an instant ...but they like ones with fuzz. Especially ones with long legs and arms that sling around I picked up a new one for each of them today at Target. They have great toys. They stand up to the tug of wars that go on every night.
I was looking through all the toys you displayed and yes, we have a number of them! Plus lots of others. Besides Baxter, we have 2 Labs so we have a large box in the living room with toys, and one in the garage that they no longer want to play with. WHen they get tired of the ones in the house, we switch with some of the old toys in the garage. In Baxter's case, it's all new to him!